So, I just found this post online that's completely bull**** about how Twilight's better than Harry Potter and how Harry Potter sucks. Well, no offense to any twi-hards out there, but I don't think that's very true. (the article can be found here).
to refute that, I'm making a list of my own.
WHY HARRY POTTER IS AWESOME:
1. It has a plot. A good plot. It follows the Hero's Journey, in fact. I think. The point is, they have a quest, and they are on it. And they go forth and conquer.
2. It has reasonable character development. The main trio had the chance to surprise you, as did most of the supporting cast. Like Neville.
3. No character is totally perfect. If someone is beautiful, they have a messed up home life (like Draco). If they're really nice or smart, they're probably not attractive (like Hermione).
4. There are themes - friendship, bravery, doing what's right even when you're heartbroken. That's something I didn't really learn from Twilight.
5. It actually has humor. And good villains. (and by 'good villains,' I mean 'villains that are developed, have motives, and who I want to punch in the face at times.' Unlike the Volturi, who were a threat in theory and not in reality.)
6. I nearly cried when Dobby died. Though I did feel kind of depressed when Bella threw herself off a cliff, I think it might have partially been because she didn't die.
7. Dumbledore. Not much more needs to be said. He's brilliant. And who says elderly gay dudes are creeps? I know no creepy gay dudes. I know no creepy gay people, period.
WHY TWILIGHT ISN'T BRILLIANT:
1. Bella doesn't act; she reacts. The one time she acted she did it for love (to stop Edward from going out in the sun and bugging the Volturi), which is noble and all, but it was sort of like... why? Jacob made her happy. Why couldn't Edward have come back and had there been tension while she had feelings for both of them.
2. Edward. Ew. Sure, he's hot, but he's... I dunno. Sketchy? Creepy? Obsessive? He watches her in her sleep, for crying out loud. Sure, I mean I guess that's romantic, but I wouldn't want a boyfriend doing that. I might not be able to sleep if that happened.
3. The Volturi were cool, but they didn't pose much of a threat. I mean, they didn't really DO anything. They didn't really pose any threat, and they didn't have any annoying rules that Bella had to get around until the end of the fourth one. Which brings me to my next point.
4. The end of the fourth book. Ew. It could have redeemed a good chunk of the series with its epic battle and the desperation to make sure everyone good came out alive, and probably could have had some tragic, tear-inducing deaths. But it didn't. It was just Edward and Ari having a thought-discussion. Bella wasn't even in on it. AND THEY HAD AMASSED A FREAKING ARMY. WHY DIDN'T THEY DO ANYTHING WITH IT?
5. There could have been some tension with possibly introducing any of Bella's human friends into the supernatural world. One of Bella's human friends could have had an idea and have tried to get in on it and stirred stuff up. Edward even specifically said that Carlisle could barely pass for the age he was claiming to be - why wasn't someone outside of Jacob's community suspicious of it?
6. Most of the characters, with the possible exception of Jacob, are completely flat. Harry, Ron, and Hermione can surprise you. They have depth. Jacob was the only one who actually was pained by any decision he or anyone else ever made.
In short:
HARRY POTTER: Plot, characters, surprises, action, crying.
TWILIGHT: some action, bending of rules of grammar and supernatural beings.